I recently supported a client to recruit its first new chief executive in 30 years.
It was a significant moment for the organisation, and the client has chosen to approach the appointment differently. Alongside a full search and selection process, they have invested in our Peridot Plus service, which will support chief executive induction and probation, followed by a 360-degree review once they are established.
Rather than our relationship ending when the successful candidate accepts the job, the organisation and its new chief executive would receive our support for 12 to 18 months.
We deliver this part of the programme in collaboration with Vicky Hossack, a former charity chief executive and Level 7 CIPD-qualified HR practitioner. She understands the personal and organisational reality of taking responsibility as a charity chief executive, while also bringing the professional HR expertise needed for this service.
It is the first time one of our clients has selected our full Peridot Plus package, and the experience has already taught us that the way a board plans to support its next chief executive can make a real difference to its ability to recruit them.
Candidates are looking beyond the recruitment process
When I speak with prospective chief executives, they don’t only ask about the job description and salary.
They want to understand the board. Is it supportive? Does it understand the distinction between governance and management? What is its relationship with the current chief executive? What will the handover look like? What support will be available during the first few months?
Taking on a chief executive role always involves risk. That risk can feel particularly significant when someone is considering their first CEO position or succeeding a long-serving and well-regarded leader.
As a recruiter, I can’t always offer much detail about what the induction will involve or how the board will help the successful candidate establish themselves.
This process has been different because I could tell candidates that the board has invested in independent support from someone who understands both sides of the relationship.
Several candidates have told me that they have never encountered such a comprehensive approach to recruiting and supporting a chief executive. It has reassured them about the quality and intentions of the board and encouraged them to take the opportunity seriously and submit an application.
Chief executive induction reveals a board's priorities
Recruitment is a two-way process. The board is assessing whether candidates have the skills, experience and values required to lead the charity. At the same time, candidates are assessing whether the organisation will provide the conditions they need to succeed.
A board’s approach to chief executive induction says as much as the recruitment process itself. It tells candidates that the trustees recognise their responsibility does not end when an offer is accepted.
It also suggests that probation will be treated as a constructive, two-way process rather than a single judgement made at the end of six months.
Working with an independent practitioner gives the incoming chief executive someone who understands the realities of their role, while also helping the board establish clear expectations and approach difficult or sensitive conversations fairly.
No chief executive should have to write their own induction
There is a familiar joke in the charity sector that chief executives often write their own induction. Like many jokes, it persists because there is some truth behind it.
A new CEO may arrive to find an organisation focused on operational pressures, a board unsure about its role during the transition and a handover that depends largely on what the outgoing leader has had time to prepare.
The incoming chief executive is then expected to identify what they need to know, build their own relationships and establish the measures against which their early performance will be assessed. That is a considerable burden, particularly for a first-time chief executive.
A strong chief executive induction should still give the incoming leader space to shape their own approach. Designing the process shouldn’t fall to them alone.
We can work with the board and incoming CEO to develop an induction that is structured without being restrictive and shaped around the particular context of the organisation.
The goal is to make sure the new chief executive is never left to navigate the transition alone.
Read more: How to get CEO and Chair succession planning right
Probation should support success
Probation can sometimes be treated as a date in the diary when the board confirms whether the chief executive has passed. A meaningful probation process should be more constructive than that.
Both the board and chief executive should understand from the beginning what success will look like. There should be regular opportunities to discuss progress, changing circumstances, areas where further support is needed and the quality of the relationship between the CEO and trustees.
The same principle applies to 360-degree feedback, which can provide valuable insight into how the chief executive is perceived across the organisation. It can recognise what is working, identify areas for development and open up conversations that might otherwise be avoided.
Induction shapes success long after appointment
Recruitment processes naturally focus on reaching an appointment. It is a visible milestone and an important one. But appointing a strong candidate doesn’t guarantee they’ll become an excellent chief executive for that organisation.
It requires clear expectations, a healthy relationship with the chair and trustees, constructive feedback and opportunities for both the chief executive and the board to learn.
Our role is to help the board and its new chief executive build the foundations for a successful, sustainable relationship.
I have been struck by how much confidence candidates have taken from knowing those structures will be in place. It has reminded me that induction should be part of the organisation’s thinking from the very beginning.
If boards want to attract strong chief executives, perhaps they should spend a little less time asking only, “Who do we want to appoint?”
They should also ask, “What will we do to help them succeed?”
If you’d like us to support you with chief executive recruitment and induction, please get in touch with Bill or Vicky.
Bill Yuksel is our Head of SME Charities, with over 60 CEO appointments across England, Wales and Scotland. He has a true passion for social change and a drive to match motivated candidates with organisations where they can make a difference.
Vicky Hossack is our Associate Head of HR. With extensive experience across the charity and voluntary sectors across the UK, Vicky is passionate about supporting employers to create vibrant, inclusive spaces for their teams to thrive.